Tent or Swap? Gas or Butane stove?

Discussion on what, where & how to get there ...
Post Reply
User avatar
Jerrad
Junior Member
Posts: 35
Joined: Fri Jan 06, 2012 9:24 am
Location: Hastings, Victoria

Tent or Swap? Gas or Butane stove?

Post by Jerrad » Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:07 pm

So for a single guy trying to save space (fridge/esky & dog) and comfort would you go for Swag or Tent?
And which swag is best?
I currently have a hiking tent which is awesome! and I use either a double oztrail self inf mattress (when had a GF) or my hiking self inf single (thin). The double mattress fits behind the front seats going across so it doesnt move when I squash it down.

Any advice on brands or gas over butane?
I only have a Trangia for my cooking currently, which is amazing! I was thinking of getting a SMALL gas bottle and a 2 burner stove.

I could cont as I am for a while but Id like to do a trip to Fraser Island once I have a lift.
Thanks! Jerrad!
OFFROAD NOOB MODDING

User avatar
taza
General Member
Posts: 1417
Joined: Sun Dec 26, 2010 10:21 pm
Location: Perth, Australia

Post by taza » Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:15 pm

Jerrad wrote:So for a single guy trying to save space (fridge/esky & dog) and comfort would you go for Swag or Tent?
And which swag is best?
I currently have a hiking tent which is awesome! and I use either a double oztrail self inf mattress (when had a GF) or my hiking self inf single (thin). The double mattress fits behind the front seats going across so it doesnt move when I squash it down.

Any advice on brands or gas over butane?
I only have a Trangia for my cooking currently, which is amazing! I was thinking of getting a SMALL gas bottle and a 2 burner stove.

I could cont as I am for a while but Id like to do a trip to Fraser Island once I have a lift.
Swag all the way mate. It will outlast a tent and you just role it up and pack it away. Otherwise you still need a matress, sleeping bag and the rest with a tent. It does take up more room but can go on the roof and do role up quite small when you don't leave your pillow and sheets in it.

I have a aussie brand one, can't remember the name but its great. Only 2years old now but covered in rull dust and gets used frequently.

User avatar
Venom
General Member
Posts: 1044
Joined: Sun Feb 03, 2008 10:04 am
Location: Ballarat

Post by Venom » Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:20 pm

I went from a gas stone to a trangia to save some weight and space after seeing how Dulagarl setup his cooking arrangements. Gas you can get bigger bottles but you never know how empty they are, same with butane but you can carry a few spares. With a traingia you know exactly how much fuel you have spare and you can buy metho from pretty much anywhere.

I would have thought a swag would be huge in the car compared to a hiking tent and self inflating mattress? Heavier too. My g/f and i use a big double swag which sits on the back seat snuggly from door to door, love it and wouldn't use anything else. The thing i like most is that they are pitch black untill you open it. Not sure what brand it is, just picked it up from Rays.
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

User avatar
Brumby Kid
General Member
Posts: 1297
Joined: Sun Jul 17, 2011 9:19 pm
Location: Belair S.A.

Post by Brumby Kid » Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:38 pm

Tent vs swag depends how long it will be until you need room for two.
And trangia all the way! We use them on school camps and since then I have bought one.
They are awesome, you can even get a gas burner attachment if you want.
But metho is still a good flame. Don't use shelite!!! I was sold it, then asked a camp instructor what is best and was told it would make a bomb! ( coz of the way the burner works ).

Cheers Cam
When life gives you a corner, drop a gear, pitch, and stomp the loud pedal
Bianca: 1991 Subaru Brumby
My First / Project car

EA81 Rebuilt by Tony Knight from knight Engines
2" body lift
25" 185r14 Yokahama Delivery Star, light truck tyres
2" Sports exhaust
Rear Aguip step/bar
Liberty seats
"Bianca"
[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Dads Car: 02 Impreza WRX STi
Mums Car 08 Liberty Wagon

User avatar
alang
Junior Member
Posts: 225
Joined: Thu Nov 03, 2011 9:18 pm
Location: Newcastle NSW

Post by alang » Fri Mar 16, 2012 9:50 pm

old biker sleeping bag with a ground sheet wrapped around it. normally just take the ground sheet and hang it from the bike with part of under the sleeping bag 2 pegs hold it down as with stove i have a fuel stove small has a one litre aluminium bottle burns any liquid fuel petrol metho change the jet and will burn diesel has a pump to prime and a starter pad.

when in the car i take a swag and have a cheap $20 single burner butene stove it takes the cans of gas at $2.00 a can normally good for 3 meals per can bacon and eggs for brecky sausages for lunch and steak for dinner on a cast iron pan or dutch oven with home made casserole instead of steak

User avatar
Silverbullet
Senior Member
Posts: 2858
Joined: Mon Aug 23, 2010 6:20 pm
Location: Adelaide

Post by Silverbullet » Fri Mar 16, 2012 11:21 pm

I've got a thick canvas single swag which has a 2 inch foam mattress in it, also has 2 bendy poles for the head and middle of the swag to create a space inside, and a guide rope at either end. It's a "Mad dog morgan" quite a few years old now. Honestly I much prefer camping in even a single person dome tent; the tent is smaller, lighter, actually easier to set up than my swag (bendy poles aren't that bendy, snapped them multiple times) and you can get changed more easily in a tent than a swag. I find the swag hard to roll up and it is quite huge when rolled up.

There are lots of different styles of swag out there, from a sheet folded in half with a zipper around it to almost a full blown tent, the one I've got all said and done is quite a pain to live with. I still kinda like camping in it though :)
Will it ever end!?
-EA81 TWIN CARB!!!!
-L series 5 speed
-Custom paint job
-2" lift
-Full custom re-wire
-L series front end
Image

User avatar
longy99gt
Junior Member
Posts: 267
Joined: Mon Apr 19, 2010 3:23 pm
Location: Perth-WA
Contact:

Post by longy99gt » Fri Mar 16, 2012 11:23 pm

if you want a good swag, buy A.O.S
aussie made, tuff stuff!!
the tracker is their most versatile option, and once you know how to get the most out of it, its brilliant,
or for still good, almost as versatile, but slightly easier to use its the Down Under Brumby,
(good name too)

but seriously, i've spent the last 8 years selling stuff in a camping store, so if ya wanna know anything camping, PM me,

as for tents, they will be smaller, and with a good self inflating mattres, and good sleeping bag, you will have a more compact set overall, all of which are easy enough to set up if you get the good quality gear, and you have far more space to get changed, and hide from the elements, i could even set up my 4'x2' table in my 3 man tent to play cards while in a storm.........
but the darkness of a swag is pretty handy, stops the light coming in too early in the morning as long as its a good one that wont let you down in the rain, get a Double ended dome swag, not a 3 pole set dome swag, or single hoop...double hoops the better option.
stoves, the coleman dual fuel is the better option,
runs on unleaded, and you know how much you have left,
you can prefill the small tank for a night or two, or take a 5L jerry can for a couple weeks worth or even more,
gas a is a good option, with the right versatile set up,
trangia is compact and efficient, but very slow, not a versatile, perfect for hiking, not as ideal for 4wdriving,


as good as cast iron gear is, (some of the best meals you'll have with the best experiences)
you cant always light fires, (too often the case)
and if you pull over oin the side for a quick lunch, you cant just rip up a quick fire like you can light a gas stove,
those lil butane stoves arent really that good.....
i've got a stove thats smaller when packed up,
has 2 burners, both are 25% hotter,
and runs off small cannisters, or normal LPG tanks

i think i'm running out of characters so i'll cut it short there!
lol sorry guys...


Longy
"SUUBMARINE"

Previous Previous- 92 LX liberty wagon 5MT, FWD

Previous- 99 GT fozzy white/grey, 5MT,
UHF / 3" >2.5" exhuast / metal sump guard / custom snorkel / 2" lift / 215/70R16 ATR's / custom pine/ply boot with fridge mount/ 2 deep cycle batteries, spotties on UNIbar

Current Project: 2007 XT 5MT Urban Grey Forester
Subaextreme Bullbar and sump guard. GME 5W Super Compact UHF. Custom Boot with Deep cycle 100A Battery, Tools storage, solar controller and low Volt shut off, with Anderson input and outputs.
Whiteline HD Adjustable front and rear sway bars
Whiteline front tower brace and ultrex rear tower brace.
235/50/17 street tires, 235/60/16 ATR's
KYB struts with Raised HD Iron Man Springs. 1"Subtle Solutions strut top blocks.
20" LED Front Light Bar
Side Shade Awning on roof racks with 2x 18W LED Flood lights and 3x LED string lights in awning

Future: Solar Panel roof mounted(under roof basket), Low range Conversion (1.44), HD clutch, 3">2.5"TBE, Rear tire carrier,

User avatar
taza
General Member
Posts: 1417
Joined: Sun Dec 26, 2010 10:21 pm
Location: Perth, Australia

Post by taza » Fri Mar 16, 2012 11:46 pm

longy99gt wrote:if you want a good swag, buy A.O.S
aussie made, tuff stuff!!
the tracker is their most versatile option, and once you know how to get the most out of it, its brilliant,
or for still good, almost as versatile, but slightly easier to use its the Down Under Brumby,
(good name too)
That was the name of mine. A.O.S
They thing, was an 18th Birthday present and will probably last me the next 30 years. By then it will be in need of a new mattress ;)

User avatar
Phizinza
General Member
Posts: 1444
Joined: Mon Oct 10, 2005 10:00 am
Location: SA
Contact:

Post by Phizinza » Fri Dec 07, 2012 2:16 pm

I like my butane stoves. $13 a stove, $1.30 a can that lasts for more than 2 hours. Maybe not the most compact or light, but at least I can cook on it using my 300x200mm BBQ hot plate. They get hot quickly, and are surprisingly tunable when it comes to heat. Only issue (as with most gas powered cooking) is they are very susceptible to wind. But that is why they include a nifty wind break, which also triples as a sink and case!

As for tent or swag, I have both and dislike both. The swag gets way too hot in summer (anything over 25 degree night and I have trouble sleeping in it). The tent is a PITA to setup and takes more than 1 minute. That is way I built the bed into the back of the Outback. Its like a swag, only fits two easy enough and has a 100mm mattress. Along with power windows and with a little messing around flyscreen too.
Owned - 89 Brumby, 83 Wagon, 83 Leone 4WD Sedan, 83 Touring Wagon, 99 Outback
Own - 87 Brumby, 93 Liberty, 09 Forester
Offroading Subarus Facebook Page


User avatar
AlpineRaven
Senior Member
Posts: 3682
Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 10:00 am
Location: Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.

Post by AlpineRaven » Fri Dec 07, 2012 5:12 pm

I have both - Butane and gas stoves, The gas stove is good for windy environment because it has hood on the sides and the back when you set it up. Butane stove is no good in windy area, last time i went camping i took butane on the beach and it was nearly impossible to boil water up hence took longer than stove would, reason i took it was space saving. My stove is about 500mm wide 300mm long with 2 burners.

Tent - I always have someone to share with me never had swag.
Cheers
AP
Subarus that I have/had:
1995 Liberty "Rallye" - 5MT AWD, LSD - *written off 25/8/06 in towing accident.
1996 Liberty Wagon - SkiFX AWD 5MT D/R, Lifted.. Outback Sway Bar, 1.59:1 Low Gearing see thread: 1.59:1 in EJ Box Page
Sold at 385,000kms in July 2011.
2007 Liberty BP Wagon, 2.5i automatic
Image

User avatar
FROG
General Member
Posts: 1409
Joined: Fri Feb 23, 2007 12:41 pm
Location: UNDER THE SOUTHERN CROSS GRIFFITH NSW
Contact:

Post by FROG » Fri Dec 07, 2012 8:33 pm

Ive recently bought a 3 second tent in the pursuit of short set up times , you throw it in the air and it pops up and you just nail it down = takes me a little more than 3 seconds but its pretty quick to set up although is quite big in its bag packed up

This winter I had an inflatable double mattress with a cigarette lighter plug to inflate - I find these mattresses a little time consuming but kept my old back off the cold river banks providing it keeps pressure :-) I just took my bedding from home
planning on a self inflating mattress for christmas

Image

Had a swag in the nineties but wasnt much of a fan , find them hot and constrictive

I have a square cast iron pan which I cook everything in over hot coals but when the fire ban is on I run the cheap briefcase gas burner - great value I think

stainless billy and Im set :-)
ImageImageImageImageImage
GRAB THE VIN FROM DONOR VEHICLES
AUSubaru member specials
Brumby EA81 Oil Pump kit (4 x 'o'rings + gasket) posted Australia wide $22!
Brumby sloppy shifter bush kit $44 posted
email me
http://www.domsmotors.com.au
NOW DISTRIBUTING FOR SUBAXTREME BASH PLATES, NUDGE AND BULLBARS

User avatar
vincentvega
Senior Member
Posts: 2446
Joined: Tue Oct 04, 2005 10:00 am
Location: Brisvegas
Contact:

Post by vincentvega » Fri Dec 07, 2012 8:34 pm

have a look at Saul swags. I love mine

When travelling light i use my Saul swag when it is cold and when it is warm you cant beat a hennessey hammock!

When the mrs tags along, a nice big canvas touring tent does the job.
Image
brumbyrunner wrote:And just to clarify the real 4WD thing, Subarus are an unreal 4WD.

User avatar
Bantum
General Member
Posts: 1923
Joined: Sun Jul 29, 2012 4:30 pm
Location: Northern Territory + QLD
Contact:

Camping ...

Post by Bantum » Sat Dec 08, 2012 2:57 am

I've done a few camp styles in my time : Various Tents, Back of Ute / Van, Hammock, Grass ... ;)

The best & comfy was the hammock, if you can stay in it that is. I've got some pic's some where ... Back of Brumby is relatively easy to set up with the tray open it's just long enough ... :)

You can't beat a log fire ( for spuds, etc ) but if you can manage it, a gas bbq offers the best in cooking - Also used the 'emergency' survival kit style heater, takes ages for it cook anything ... :(

Of course towing a small van is also the ultimate in touring luxuries, but that's another story ... :p

P.S. - You might want to correct the heading :
Tent or Swap ?
Unless you ment something else ?

User avatar
60766244
Junior Member
Posts: 586
Joined: Fri Nov 09, 2012 3:32 pm
Location: Kalamunda, Western Australia

My 2c

Post by 60766244 » Mon Dec 10, 2012 10:52 am

I have a fair bit of camping gear due to my love of a good deal and getting Bunnings Fever every time I enter an outdoor place. :rolleyes:

"I must stay off gumtree, I must stay off gumtree!"

This said I have two main groups of camping gear I use depending on where I am going.

I have a $100 (second hand) canvas Kimberly-Style tent I use in conjunction with a swag and camp-bed for when I am fancy-camping on my block. I bought both the swag and the bed from Tusker Canvas in Midland WA - Very cheap swag and bed and they've held up extremely well. The 75mm mattress is excellent too for when I don't have the folding bed.

I have two sleeping bags, one is +1c to +10c and the other bag is much fluffier at -10c to -1c for when I go into the southwest.

The other sleeping set is much lighter and consists of a Platatac bivvy bag, one of the sleeping bags and a small mattress. All that packs up into a space less than a packed ultralight tent. I use this while hiking.

For cooking I have used Trangias, Jet-Stoves, $13 Butane-Briefcase Stoves and the Titanium Ultra-Compact gas stoves.

The Trangias are good so long as you like the way they cook. They're durable and simple and hard to break but every time I try cook something complex on them (Like bacon, :rolleyes: ) It fails horribly.

The Jet-Stoves are great and fast but hyper expensive and you can only cook bagged things and pre-cooked stuff.

The Brief-case stoves are simplest I feel for car-camping and my local Bunnings sells the canisters to fit for ~$1 per can. Sometimes less when on special. You can also get lanterns that take the canisters so you can use the same fuel for light and heat. :)

I like the Ultra-Compact folding gas stoves for hiking because they're very controllable with the heat they give out and very small.

Other than all that a tripod with a billy and a skillet can cook you anything and are super simple.
Otter the 2004 Outback with all the fruit.
Image
Possible Improvements: Rigid 12db Phone Aerial Fitted, Air-compressor w/ Hose & Air-Tank, Jerry Holders, Lift, Nudgebar and Spots?

|| Ausubaru Wiki: New AUSubaru Wiki, About the Wiki || My Ex, Maple the Brumby, Rack, Lift Kit, Raptor-Liner Tray || Shed: Benches ||


User avatar
El_Freddo
Master Member
Posts: 12487
Joined: Tue Oct 04, 2005 10:00 am
Location: Bridgewater Vic
Contact:

Post by El_Freddo » Mon Dec 10, 2012 4:34 pm

Venom wrote:i use a big double swag which sits on the back seat snuggly from door to door, love it and wouldn't use anything else.
So what changed? :P
FROG wrote:Ive recently bought a 3 second tent in the pursuit of short set up times
All the QLD boys (and girls) had them when we went up the high country. I think they may have paid the price in the sleeping temp department though!

An old thread dig from earlier this year, but to answer the OP:

It seems that you've already got some good gear there for touring in your car - why add more gear than you really need? I've now got two camping kits really - hiking/canoeing etc and 4wd touring. The touring setup I've been working on for some time to have everything secured for the offroading as well as being organised throughout my trips now.

To keep it simple, light and maybe short in length of your trips (weekend etc) all you need is your hiking setup and the trangia. Venom loves his. I've got a two burner gas stove with griller (because I can! And the best parma's are in the bush IMO). The back up stove is my hiking coleman dual fuel stove that runs on ULP.

I used to use the units that Phiz talks about, but when touring in winter we were CHEWING through the canisters and I have an issue with the single use of said canisters. Also they don't work so well in the cold when they're in use as they act like your air con does.

Really at the end of the day, take advice, check out other's setups and work out from there what it is you want your kit to be able to do for you and what products will do it the best while fitting in the car etc.

On the note of Swags - I'm not sold on them. And at what point does a swag stop being a swag and become a tent with all the poles and ropes they come with these days?

I hope Venom drops in here and shares his swap from swag to tent ;)

Cheers

Bennie
"The lounge room is not a workshop..."
Image
El Freddo's Pics - El_Freddo's youtube

User avatar
Rodeo4jake
Junior Member
Posts: 297
Joined: Fri Oct 19, 2012 5:42 am
Location: Tylden Victoria

Post by Rodeo4jake » Mon Dec 10, 2012 7:41 pm

G'day
My 2 cents on this is that when I was travelling in utes for many years I loved the quick setup & pack up of swags. But as soon as we got our 4wd wagon(the make of which I have realised can't be discussed here)we got a canvas single pole touring tent & my wife loved having somewhere to get dressed in privacy. Swags waste a lot of space.
The stove we hav is a 3 burner LPG that we have had for 14 years. I too don't like throwing butane cans away all the time. We have travelled for 7 weeks straight cooking & using gas light on 1 3.5kg gas bottle. Only problem is that the law does say you can't carry LPG cylinders inside your car.

Cheers Jake

Post Reply

Return to “Camping and Travel”